I was so excited to finally try the El Coto Rioja last night after my Rueda disappointment on Sunday. Here he is, in all his regal, gold fishnet-wrapped glory (I felt a from-below shot would be more fitting for this bad boy):

I couldn’t get over the beautiful ruby color of the wine:

After drooling over the color alone, I took my first sniff. I noticed immediately the prominent red fruit- cherry, strawberries, raspberries, plus a little funk (which you know I love), and a little earth. Oh yeah, I was into it. Then I took a sip… WHAT?!? Where had all the complexity of the nose gone? Where was the funk? Where was the earth? After building up the Rioja so much in my mind, I was crushed (wine pun not-intended) to discover that though it had a lovely, long finish, something was missing on the palate. It was like finally being set up with that gorgeous guy you’ve been eyeing for months only to discover he has ZERO sense of humor or personality. AWKWARD. Yeah, that’s kind of how this wine tasting was.
Ok, he had some redeeming qualities- I’ll stop using date analogies to describe the wine and give you the actual tasting notes. There was lovely red fruit and stone fruit present, a bit of slate, a bit of anise, and the finish was beautifully long (thanks to the noble, old Tempranillo grapes.) I suppose I was just hoping for a little more roundness, a little more complexity. It was only $10.99 after all, but still… at that price point you should definitely be able to find some delicious, pretty complex wines.
One mistake I made in retrospect was not having this wine with food. I definitely don’t think it’s an easy-drinking wine- it’s so dry it is begging to cut into a NY strip or a ribeye, roasted chicken with mashed potatoes, or even a pizza (yeah, I said it.)
Let’s not give up on Rioja’s, though… there are some AMAZING ones out there. I’ll make it a mission to find one for you all. Does anyone have a go-to Rioja that they are just dying to share? Hook a wino up.